Ian Gavan / Getty Images Entertainment / Getty Images
A federal judge in New Jersey has dismissed a defamation lawsuit filed against the producers od Christian Bale and Woody Harrelson’s new movie over the movie’s portrayal of Native Americans.
Some members of the Ramapough Lunaape Nation consider the movie to have some unsavory characters bearing last names of some of their community memebers. It includes a villain, crime ringleader Harlan DeGroat, portrayed by Harrelson.
A total of 17 plaintiffs, eight of whom bear the name DeGroat, demand compensation, because the movie describes the gang as the community of “inbreds”. The lawsuit was filed in December 2013.
In April, bosses at Leonardo DiCaprio’s production firm Appian Way Productions and Relativity Media asked for dismissal. They cited the U.S. Constitution’s First Amendment freedom of speech right.
On Wednesday, May 14, U.S. District judge William Walls granted the request.
His ruling said, “Plaintiffs plead only that some of them share the same surname, but not first name, as two of the characters in the movie.
They also contend that they are Ramapoughs, as are the characters in the movie, and that many of them live in the same region as the Ramapoughs. These allegations do not suffice to show that the alleged defamatory statements are ‘of and concerning’ these Plaintiffs.”
As a reaction to the news, a Relativity Media spokesperson says, “We are pleased with the New Jersey Federal Court’s decision today to dismiss the complaint…
As we have said all along, the picture is not based upon any particular person or group of people, and the Court agreed with us on this point. We are satisfied that the court has upheld the right of free speech in the context of this purely fictional film.”
No one is immune to affairs, not even the most boring among us nor the mostly saintlike. These things...
Many will argue that today’s stars can’t compete with the star power of vintage Hollywood, but we disagree. Here...
It’s only safe to assume that celebrities (being the ever so interesting folk that we can’t help but gossip...
There are many common learning disabilities that lots of people have and need to overcome in order to become...
It is a tragedy whenever we lose a beloved celebrity, especially if their death was meaningless and avoidable. However,...
No one is immune to affairs, not even the most boring among us nor the mostly saintlike. These...
Many will argue that today’s stars can’t compete with the star power of vintage Hollywood, but we disagree....
It’s only safe to assume that celebrities (being the ever so interesting folk that we can’t help but...
There are many common learning disabilities that lots of people have and need to overcome in order to...
It is a tragedy whenever we lose a beloved celebrity, especially if their death was meaningless and avoidable....
No one is immune to affairs, not even the most boring among us nor the mostly saintlike. These...
Many will argue that today’s stars can’t compete with the star power of vintage Hollywood, but we disagree....
It’s only safe to assume that celebrities (being the ever so interesting folk that we can’t help but...
There are many common learning disabilities that lots of people have and need to overcome in order to...
It is a tragedy whenever we lose a beloved celebrity, especially if their death was meaningless and avoidable....
People often think of celebrities as divine beings – entities no living mortal can even dare approach, let...
No one is immune to affairs, not even the most boring among us nor the mostly saintlike. These...
Many will argue that today’s stars can’t compete with the star power of vintage Hollywood, but we disagree....
It’s only safe to assume that celebrities (being the ever so interesting folk that we can’t help but...
There are many common learning disabilities that lots of people have and need to overcome in order to...
It is a tragedy whenever we lose a beloved celebrity, especially if their death was meaningless and avoidable....
People often think of celebrities as divine beings – entities no living mortal can even dare approach, let...